Hi, I'm Daniel the coder behind www.sociafyq.com.
I just accidentally came across this thread and I had to register since I felt a need to respond to your post.
All your comments have been addressed (some with just a question back - the rest have been implemented).
Here's a comment on each one of yours from the current moment point of view:
1."If you think text is important enough to warrant a font-size of 60px, then why not use a <h1> "
> has been done by dave
2. "Guess you weren't expecting visitors with a resolution of 1920x1200? Footer is repeating..."
> Yeah, I fixed that when I got me a wide mon and saw the problem
3. "'d make the 'mainmenu' an <ul><li>...d by the pipe character | "
> Well the | is part of the design I think (which I'm not responsible for)... Is there any particular reason why a list should be used ? Applies for "... links on the left should again ..." too.
4. "Your logo is a div instead of an image,..."
> I believe Dave has taken care of this and I just set the alt
5. "http://sociafyq.com/ci/spublic/about would be good to have alt text with something like ..."
> Done
6. " but where's the h1 preceding them? Should probably be the text you get there with the blue background."
> Done
7. "http://sociafyq.com/ci/forum/ had me fooled f... someone uses labels for a change ...x was dissapointe"
> Not sure which place in the forum you refer to (perhaps the login form), but all labels throughout "our" part of the site either surround the field they are meant to or [for] it. Is there any more issues involved regarding that part?
Anyway you should direct the forum comments to Dave I believe.
8. "As a personal preference I also prefer my forums at 100% width ..."
> I believe Dave has just used a stock template on the forum and since it's not yet a major priority for the site (and also we don't have a designer ) it's just left as it is.
9. "You got a nice lightweight page, but it can be lighter according to smushit as it states a saving of 9.04% can be accomplished..."
> Do you mean the markup or the resources?
I noticed that ALL images could be optimized further, cropped, combined or better yet removed (like I did with the footer image when looked at the page at 1680x1050 for the first time ) . And not only images...
I'm just letting the design settle for a while (also didn't have a red channel on my old monitor) then will compress and optimize all resources and their usage.
10. "Another personal preference of mine is to have the logo at the top link back to the homepage..."
> Sure it's everyone's I believe Dave has done that a while a go.
11. As of the longdesc attribute I think we still rely that a SEO expert will join our efforts for any major or final touches since non of us is willing to take the responsibility for that I believe
All your comments - past and further have and will be greatly appreciated (I can't describe how much so I'll try to make it show ).
Thanks and expecting more from you (perhaps on the functionality as well - feel free to use our forum for that).
Daniel